Tyler Shough

Career StatsC

Year	Team	GP	Yards	TD	INT	RTG
Career		11	2,384	10	6	91.3
2025		11	2,384	10	6	91.3

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

The Saints struck solid value with Tyler Shough's four-year, $10.8M deal, landing what appears to be a fair contract for serviceable starter production at the league's most important position. At $2.7M per year with full guaranteed money, this represents shrewd roster building for a quarterback who profiles as a competent backup with legitimate starting upside — a commodity that typically commands $8-12M annually in today's market. The front-loaded guarantee structure minimizes long-term risk while giving New Orleans flexibility to develop Shough or pivot if needed, making this a low-stakes, high-reward investment. For a franchise navigating the post-Drew Brees era, securing a serviceable starter at well below market rate provides crucial depth and potential competition for the starting role without hamstringing future cap flexibility. This B CVI reflects exactly the type of calculated risk successful franchises take on young quarterbacks with developmental promise, offering New Orleans legitimate quarterback insurance at a bargain price point.

Performance Analysis

Tyler Shough arrives in New Orleans as a 26-year-old rookie with a winding college road behind him, now earning his first real NFL opportunity with the Saints. For a first-year starter, his early returns merit a C grade — functional but unspectacular, sitting in the developmental middle ground most rookie quarterbacks occupy. Compared to historical rookie benchmarks, he's neither alarming nor exciting, projecting as a learn-on-the-job starter rather than an immediate difference-maker. The efficiency numbers tell a mixed story. His 91.3 passer rating and 67.6 completion percentage both clear NFL averages of 77.2 and 64.2 respectively, and his 7.29 yards per attempt edges the league norm of 6.90 — encouraging signs of ball placement and decision-making. The glaring concern is his TD rate of just 3.06 percent against a league average of 4.50, suggesting he struggles to convert field position into touchdowns, a critical deficiency for any quarterback hoping to stick. His 216.7 passing yards per game trails the NFL average of 230.0, reflecting a conservative offensive deployment that may be limiting his upside. Watch his red-zone decision-making and touchdown production as the clearest indicators of growth. If Shough can push that TD rate toward league average while maintaining his above-average efficiency, the Saints have a viable bridge starter — and potentially more.

Current Sentiment

Tyler Shough enters the 2026 NFL season as one of the more intriguing developmental quarterback stories in the league, with the New Orleans Saints making a clear organizational statement through their 2026 draft class. Multiple analysts and media outlets noted that the Saints' draft appeared singularly focused on surrounding their young signal-caller with skill-position talent, a vote of confidence from the front office that has not gone unnoticed. Fantasy football communities and NFL observers alike identified Shough as a notable winner of the draft cycle, with his supporting cast receiving a meaningful upgrade heading into the season. The narrative around Shough is cautiously optimistic rather than effusive — he remains an unproven commodity at the NFL level, and the modest contract reflects the organization's measured approach to his development. Nevertheless, the convergence of front-office investment and positive media framing positions Shough as a legitimate starter-in-waiting with growing momentum, making him one of the more closely watched young quarterbacks entering the new season.