FanVerdicts
NFLNBAMLB
FanVerdicts
TransactionsPlayersTeamsGMsDraftTrade ValuesLiveScoresArticles
Sign In

FanVerdicts

Where fans deliver the verdict on every move in professional sports.

NFL

  • Transactions
  • Player Rankings
  • Teams
  • GM Rankings
  • Draft
  • Scores
  • Standings

NBA

  • Transactions
  • Player Rankings
  • Teams
  • GM Rankings
  • Draft
  • Scores
  • Standings

MLB

  • Transactions
  • Player Rankings
  • Teams
  • GM Rankings
  • Draft
  • Scores
  • Standings

Company

  • About
  • Methodology
  • Insights
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Key Dates

Follow

  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
© 2026 FanVerdicts. All rights reserved. Not affiliated with the NFL or any professional sports league.
Feedback

Most Underpaid NFL Contracts

The NFL bargains — strong Contract Value Index grades on below-market salaries.

NFL/Contract Value/Most Underpaid

Cap-strapped teams are built on the deals nobody complains about — the ones where a player vastly outperforms his paycheck. This page surfaces those bargains: the strongest Contract Value Index (CVI) grades on the NFL board sitting on below-median salaries.

Rookie-scale contracts dominate the conversation here, but they are not the whole story. A veteran who took a hometown discount or a mid-tier free agent on a value deal can grade just as high, because the math is the same: elite return relative to cost.

For a front office, every name on this list is a small competitive edge — money saved that can be spent somewhere else on the roster.

The 20 NFL bargains below cost just $30.4M per year combined, led by value at P — a fraction of what their grades would command on the open market.

Salary figures are average annual value. Cuts and releases are excluded — the Contract Value Index is not a valid signal on a non-contract move. Grades reflect value to the team, not raw talent.

Most Underpaid by Contract Value Index

Below-median NFL salaries earning the strongest Contract Value Index (CVI) grades. Ranked by grade quality, then by how little the team is paying.

#PlayerMoveAvg / YrCVI
1
Emari DemercadoRB · Kansas City Chiefs
Signing · 1 yr$1.3M
A+
A+
2
Corliss WaitmanP · San Francisco 49ers
Signing$1.3M
A+
A+
3
Julius ChestnutRB · Tennessee Titans
Signing · 1 yr$1.4M
A+
A+
4
Cam Taylor-BrittDB · Indianapolis Colts
Signing$1.4M
A+
A+
5
Jaleel McLaughlinRB · Denver Broncos
Signing · 1 yr$1.4M
A+
A+
6
Mitch WishnowskyP · Buffalo Bills
Signing · 1 yr$1.5M
A+
A+
7
Johnny HekkerP · Minnesota Vikings
Signing$1.5M
A+
A+
8
Johnny HekkerP · Minnesota Vikings
Signing · 1 yr$1.5M
A+
A+
9
Bradley PinionP · Miami Dolphins
Signing$1.5M
A+
A+
10
Christian RozeboomLB · Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Signing · 1 yr$1.6M
A+
A+
11
Emanuel WilsonRB · Seattle Seahawks
Signing · 1 yr$1.6M
A+
A+
12
Corey BojorquezP · Cleveland Browns
Extension · 1 yr$2.0M
A+
A+
13
Joey SlyeK · Tennessee Titans
Signing · 1 yr$2.0M
A+
A+
14
Brady RussellRB · Seattle Seahawks
Signing · 2 yr$2.4M
A+
A+
15
Eli AppleDB · San Francisco 49ers
Signing$1.3M
A
A
16
Jack StollTE · Cleveland Browns
Signing · 1 yr$1.3M
A
A
17
Mike BrownSs · New England Patriots
Signing · 1 yr$1.3M
A
A
18
Kylen GransonTE · Tennessee Titans
Signing · 1 yr$1.4M
A
A
19
Willie Gay JrILB · Miami Dolphins
Extension · 1 yr$1.4M
A
A
20
Isaiah SimmonsS · Carolina Panthers
Extension · 1 yr$1.4M
A
A
See the most overpaid deals instead →|Full best & worst value board →

What "underpaid" means here

A contract lands here when a team is getting one of the strongest Contract Value Index (CVI) grades on the board while paying below-median money — the bargains a smart front office locked in. These are the closest thing to a free win on the salary ledger. Read the full methodology.