Shy Tuttle

Career StatsF

Year	Team	GP	Sacks	Tkl	TFL
Career		107	4.5	247	16.5
2025		12	0.0	15	2
2024		15	0.0	46	1
2023		17

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

Washington landed a solid value play by securing Shy Tuttle on a one-year, $1.4M deal that earns a B- CVI grade. For a depth piece defensive tackle, this contract represents smart roster building at the margins — Tuttle brings proven NFL experience and rotational capability at a price point that won't strain the salary cap. The minimal guaranteed money ($100K) gives the Commanders maximum flexibility while the short-term commitment allows them to evaluate his fit without long-term risk. At $1.4M AAV, Washington is paying appropriate market rate for a reliable interior lineman who can contribute in sub-packages and provide valuable depth behind their starters. This is the type of under-the-radar signing that helps teams build sustainable rosters, giving the Commanders a known commodity who can step in when needed without breaking the bank or compromising future cap flexibility.

Performance Analysis

Shy Tuttle's F grade in Washington marks a significant decline for a defensive tackle who was once a productive starter in New Orleans. Tuttle signed with the Commanders expecting to be a key piece of their defensive interior, but the production has been nonexistent. His F grade reflects a player who has been invisible on the field — no impact in the run game and zero pass-rush contribution. Whether it's injuries, scheme fit, or simply a player who peaked early, the results in Washington have been terrible. The Commanders' defensive line has underperformed, and Tuttle is a major part of that underperformance. This signing looks like a miss from every conceivable angle.