J.j. Mccarthy

Career StatsC+

Year	Team	GP	Yards	TD	INT	RTG
Career		10	1,632	11	12	72.6
2025		10	1,632	11	12	72.6
2024		1	188	2	1	116.8

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

The Vikings secured solid value on their rookie quarterback investment, landing J.J. McCarthy at $5.5M AAV in what amounts to a fair deal for a developmental prospect with upside. While McCarthy's current production profile slots him as a rotational player, this rookie contract structure reflects appropriate market pricing for a quarterback selected to be groomed as Kirk Cousins' eventual successor. At his age, McCarthy sits in the optimal window for quarterback development, giving Minnesota a cost-controlled asset with four years to maximize his ceiling without salary cap strain. The fully guaranteed $21.9M represents minimal financial risk given the rookie wage scale, while the four-year timeline aligns perfectly with the team's transition planning at the position. This C+ CVI reflects a prudent organizational move — not a home run, but exactly the type of calculated investment that championship-caliber franchises make when building sustainable depth at football's most important position.

Performance Analysis

J.j. Mccarthy grades as a solid starter among NFL quarterbacks — an above-average player at the position. His strongest area is touchdown rate at 4.53 (near the NFL average of 4.50), ranking as near league average for the position. Completion percentage, at 57.6% compared to an NFL average of 64.2%, is where he falls short relative to the position. His production dropped from a C in 2024 to a D in 2025. Limited games played (10 career) reduces confidence in this grade.