Cam Miller

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

Miami's $0.9M AAV deal for Cam Miller represents a slight overpay for what appears to be a replacement-level quarterback acquisition, earning a D+ CVI that reflects questionable value even at the bottom of the market. While the Dolphins are clearly operating in the bargain bin with this signing, they're still paying above what Miller's limited NFL track record warrants for a player who profiles as nothing more than a camp arm or emergency third-string option. The short-term financial commitment keeps Miami's downside risk minimal, but the contract structure suggests they're betting on developmental upside that rarely materializes with quarterbacks of Miller's caliber. At $0.9M annually, this represents the type of low-stakes gamble that won't hurt the salary cap but also signals the Dolphins are still searching for viable depth behind their established starters. This D+ CVI reflects a deal where Miami could have likely secured similar production for less money, making it a minor misstep in an otherwise manageable transaction for organizational depth.

Performance Analysis

At 24 years old and just one game of NFL experience to his name, Cam Miller sits firmly in replacement-level territory at the quarterback position — a depth piece with a long road ahead before he registers as a meaningful contributor. His profile as a sixth-round pick (215th overall) in 2025 tells you everything about the expectations baked into his roster spot; late Day 3 selections at quarterback are developmental projects by design, not plug-and-play solutions. The performance grade reflects a player who has barely scratched the surface of pro football, with a single game of data offering almost nothing to evaluate in terms of consistent production or scheme adaptability. His most significant calling card entering Miami isn't anything he's done on the field — it's the off-field intrigue generated by a high-profile endorsement that has driven fan curiosity well beyond what his actual NFL track record warrants. The current narrative frames him precisely as a low-risk, low-reward depth addition, someone Miami parked on the 53-man roster without any expectation that he'll push for meaningful regular-season snaps. With 135 days until the regular season kicks off, Miller's value will be measured entirely in practice reps and what he can absorb in an NFL offensive system — not in gameday contributions. The sentiment around him is trending slightly upward from pure skepticism to cautious curiosity, but that arc is driven more by storyline than substance.

Fan Sentiment

A low-risk, low-reward depth addition that won't move the needle for Miami's QB room. Headlines highlight Tom Brady's endorsement, adding intrigue to an otherwise unremarkable roster move. The strongest signal is his practice squad status — he's an unproven commodity with minimal pro experience. Fans are buzzing about the Brady connection, but that hype outpaces Miller's actual NFL track record. Expect Miller to serve as a developmental arm with little chance of seeing regular-season action.