Keydrain Calligan

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

The Titans' decision to sign Keydrain Calligan to a $1.9M total deal averaging $1.0M annually earns a D+ CVI, representing a slight overpay for what appears to be depth cornerback production. While the financial commitment sits firmly in backup territory, Calligan's performance metrics suggest he's more replacement-level than the solid rotational piece this contract implies Tennessee expects. The relatively modest annual value provides some cushion, but even at this price point, the Titans are paying above-market rate for a corner who hasn't demonstrated consistent NFL-caliber coverage skills. The short-term structure does limit long-term risk, giving Tennessee flexibility to move on without major dead money if Calligan fails to develop. This signing reflects the harsh reality of cornerback depth — teams often overpay for mediocre secondary pieces because the position is so crucial, but this D+ CVI suggests the Titans could have found similar production for less money or better value elsewhere in free agency.

Performance Analysis

Keydrain Calligan is, by any honest assessment, replacement-level at this stage of his career — a 24-year-old corner who has spent his rookie season on the margins of NFL rosters rather than contributing meaningful snaps. His lone statistical entry on record is 2 tackles across 1 game, which tells you everything about his current production level: he is not an active piece of a defense, he is a name on a depth chart. There is no standout statistical strength to point to here, and the thin sample makes any positive framing a stretch. The reserve/future contract framing says it plainly — Calligan is a developmental project with a steep climb ahead just to earn a training camp roster spot, let alone a 53-man berth. Tennessee has been active this offseason adding bodies at multiple positions, and that broader roster churn signals the organization is building depth, but Calligan's path to meaningful contributions is anything but guaranteed. The sentiment around his signing was muted at best — routine roster notice coverage with no analytical community taking a strong position either way, which reflects exactly where he stands. Until he demonstrates something tangible in training camp or preseason action, calling him anything other than roster filler would be overstating the case.

Fan Sentiment

A low-risk, low-reward practice squad addition that keeps Tennessee's cornerback depth stocked. Five headlines covered this move, mostly routine roster notices with little analytical fanfare. The reserve/future contract signal confirms Calligan is a developmental project, not an immediate contributor. Fans barely noticed, though the Titans' aggressive CB search phrase hints at a broader positional overhaul. Calligan faces a steep climb just to earn a training camp roster spot in 2025.