Jeremy Crawshaw

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

The Broncos secured an absolute steal with Jeremy Crawshaw's four-year, $4.4M extension, earning an A CVI that reflects exceptional value at the punter position. Locking up a serviceable starter at just $1.1M annually represents shrewd roster management in a league where even average specialists command $2-3M per year. The contract structure heavily favors Denver with minimal guaranteed money at just $200K, creating virtually zero financial risk while providing four years of cost certainty at a premium position. Crawshaw's consistent production gives the Broncos a reliable weapon in field position battles without the salary cap burden that comes with marquee specialists. This deal exemplifies smart front office work — identifying and retaining solid contributors before they hit the open market where punter salaries have inflated significantly in recent years.

Performance Analysis

Jeremy Crawshaw earns a C- grade after a solid rookie season as the Broncos' punter. Playing all 17 games in his first NFL season shows he won the job outright and never looked back. Punters are evaluated on consistency and their ability to flip field position, and Crawshaw earned Denver's trust for the entire 2025 campaign. The one tackle suggests some involvement on coverage units beyond punting duties. Crawshaw has established himself as the Broncos' punter of the future, and the C- grade in Year 1 is a respectable starting point. If he can continue to develop his hang time and directional punting, his grade should climb in subsequent seasons.

Current Sentiment

Jeremy Crawshaw heads into the 2026 offseason with genuinely split public perception — a C sentiment grade that captures the tension between a legitimately impressive rookie accolade and a nationally visible disaster that lodged itself in the sports media cycle. The PFWA All-Rookie team selection as a punter is a rare distinction that earned Crawshaw real credibility among specialists and evaluators who watched his full body of work, but a viral Thursday Night Football performance effectively rewrote the popular narrative around him, with the social media fallout drowning out the season-long positives. That disconnect tracks with his C- performance grade — an assessement that positions him as a middling, developmental specialist rather than a proven commodity, which makes the TNF stumble feel less like an outlier and more like evidence worth scrutinizing. The Broncos' offseason activity — trading significant draft capital and adding multiple players across position groups — signals an organization firmly in win-now mode at 14-3, which raises the stakes for every roster spot and means Crawshaw will need a cleaner 2026 campaign to justify his place on a squad with championship-level aspirations. His international exemption status and minimum-level contract give Denver zero financial risk in bringing him back, but specialists have notoriously short leashes, and right now the burden of proof sits squarely with Crawshaw to reframe his story as a promising young punter who had one bad night rather than a player who cracks under primetime pressure.