FanVerdicts
NFLNBAMLB
FanVerdicts
TransactionsPlayersTeamsGMsDraftTrade ValuesLiveScoresArticles
Sign In

FanVerdicts

Where fans deliver the verdict on every move in professional sports.

NFL

  • Transactions
  • Player Rankings
  • Teams
  • GM Rankings
  • Draft
  • Scores
  • Standings

NBA

  • Transactions
  • Player Rankings
  • Teams
  • GM Rankings
  • Draft
  • Scores
  • Standings

MLB

  • Transactions
  • Player Rankings
  • Teams
  • GM Rankings
  • Draft
  • Scores
  • Standings

Company

  • About
  • Methodology
  • Insights
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Key Dates

Follow

  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
© 2026 FanVerdicts. All rights reserved. Not affiliated with the NFL or any professional sports league.
Feedback

MLB Player Rankings 2026

Every MLB player ranked by public sentiment, performance, contract value, and fan votes.

MLB/Player Rankings
Player RankingsFree Agents
PerformanceCVISentimentFan Verdict
AllSPRPC1B2B3BSSLFCFRFDH
↑ Worst First
ABCDF
#PlayerPosTeamPerfCVISentimentFan
81Nick LodoloNick LodoloSPReds
B
Top 29%
—
D+
Bottom 30%
—
80Tyler MahleTyler MahleSPGiants
B
Top 29%
B-
Top 38%
C
Around average
—
79Jack Flaherty
FirstPrevious12345NextLast151-200 of 231
Jack Flaherty
SP
Tigers
B
Top 29%
C+
Top 48% — above average
D-
Bottom 12%
—
78Stephen KolekStephen KolekSPRoyals
B
Top 29%
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
77Connor PrielippConnor PrielippSPTwins
B
Top 29%
—
A
Top 9%
—
76DAX FultonDAX FultonSPMarlins
B
Top 29%
—
D+
Bottom 30%
—
75Luis CastilloLuis CastilloSPMariners
B
Top 29%
C+
Top 48% — above average
C
Around average
—
74Cody PonceCody PonceSPBlue Jays
B
Top 29%
B-
Top 38%
F
Bottom 5%
—
73TY MaddenTY MaddenSPTigers
B
Top 29%
—
D-
Bottom 12%
—
72Dylan CeaseDylan CeaseSPBlue Jays
B+
Top 20%
C-
Below average
A+
Top 3%
—
71Kris BubicKris BubicSPRoyals
B+
Top 20%
B+
Top 20%
B-
Top 38%
—
70Kyle LeAhyKyle LeAhySPCardinals
B+
Top 20%
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
69Michael WachaMichael WachaSPRoyals
B+
Top 20%
C+
Top 48% — above average
C
Around average
—
68Andrew AbbottAndrew AbbottSPReds
B+
Top 20%
—
B+
Top 20%
—
67Clay HolmesClay HolmesSPMets
B+
Top 20%
B
Top 29%
D
Bottom 20%
—
66Coleman CrowColeman CrowSPBrewers
B+
Top 20%
—
A
Top 9%
—
65Easton McGeeEaston McGeeSPBrewers
B+
Top 20%
—
D-
Bottom 12%
—
64Jose SorianoJose SorianoSPAngels
B+
Top 20%
A-
Top 13%
B
Top 29%
—
63Hunter BarcoHunter BarcoSPPirates
B+
Top 20%
—
F
Bottom 5%
—
62Merrill KellyMerrill KellySPDiamondbacks
B+
Top 20%
—
B-
Top 38%
—
61Tyler GlasnowTyler GlasnowSPDodgers
B+
Top 20%
C
Around average
C
Around average
—
60Cristian JavierCristian JavierSPAstros
B+
Top 20%
B+
Top 20%
D-
Bottom 12%
—
59Jesus LuzardoJesus LuzardoSPPhillies
B+
Top 20%
B+
Top 20%
D-
Bottom 12%
—
58JOE RockJOE RockSPRays
B+
Top 20%
—
B-
Top 38%
—
57Joe RyanJoe RyanSPTwins
B+
Top 20%
A-
Top 13%
B+
Top 20%
—
56Jose UrquidyJose UrquidySPPirates
B+
Top 20%
A-
Top 13%
B-
Top 38%
—
55Jr RitchieJr RitchieSPBraves
B+
Top 20%
—
A
Top 9%
—
54Kevin GausmanKevin GausmanSPBlue Jays
B+
Top 20%
B-
Top 38%
A+
Top 3%
—
53Trevor McDonaldTrevor McDonaldSPGiants
B+
Top 20%
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
52Eduardo RiveraEduardo RiveraSPRed Sox
B+
Top 20%
—
B+
Top 20%
—
51Jake BennettJake BennettSPRed Sox
B+
Top 20%
—
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
50John KleinJohn KleinSPTwins
B+
Top 20%
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
49Luis GILLuis GILSPYankees
B+
Top 20%
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
48Freddy PeraltaFreddy PeraltaSPMets
A-
Top 13%
A-
Top 13%
D+
Bottom 30%
—
47Javier AssadJavier AssadSPCubs
A-
Top 13%
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
46Justin VerlanderJustin VerlanderSPTigers
A-
Top 13%
B+
Top 20%
A
Top 9%
—
45Noah SchultzNoah SchultzSPWhite Sox
A-
Top 13%
—
B+
Top 20%
—
44Trevor RogersTrevor RogersSPOrioles
A-
Top 13%
A
Top 9%
B+
Top 20%
—
43Sonny GraySonny GraySPRed Sox
A-
Top 13%
C
Around average
C
Around average
—
42Spencer StriderSpencer StriderSPBraves
A-
Top 13%
—
A+
Top 3%
—
41Trey YesavageTrey YesavageSPBlue Jays
A-
Top 13%
—
B
Top 29%
—
40George KirbyGeorge KirbySPMariners
A-
Top 13%
A
Top 9%
A-
Top 13%
—
39Logan GilbertLogan GilbertSPMariners
A-
Top 13%
A-
Top 13%
B+
Top 20%
—
38Logan HendersonLogan HendersonSPBrewers
A-
Top 13%
—
F
Bottom 5%
—
37Nathan EovaldiNathan EovaldiSPRangers
A-
Top 13%
C+
Top 48% — above average
C
Around average
—
36Framber ValdezFramber ValdezSPTigers
A-
Top 13%
C+
Top 48% — above average
A
Top 9%
—
35Hunter BrownHunter BrownSPAstros
A-
Top 13%
A+
Top 3%
D+
Bottom 30%
—
34Ranger SuarezRanger SuarezSPRed Sox
A-
Top 13%
C+
Top 48% — above average
D+
Bottom 30%
—
33Alek ManoahAlek ManoahSPAngels
A
Top 9%
—
C-
Below average
—
32Drew RasmussenDrew RasmussenSPRays
A
Top 9%
A
Top 9%
B+
Top 20%
—