Indianapolis Colts sign C Geno VanDeMark

Geno VanDeMark earns a C+ Contract Value Index (CVI) for his signing with the Colts—a depth move that makes financial sense but carries meaningful execution risk. At $1.04M AAV on a three-year deal, this is classic replacement-level center pricing, the kind of contract that lives in the league's marginal-value zone where a backup-quality starter can provide solid depth without eating into premium cap allocation. The CVI reflects what the Colts are actually buying here: a capable interior lineman on a prove-it deal during the offseason, not a franchise anchor or immediate starter with long-term upside. Whether this becomes a steal or a sunk cost depends entirely on whether VanDeMark can stay healthy and productive in a reserve-to-rotation role—the contract structure is forgiving enough to cut him loose if he underperforms, but also modest enough that it won't hamstring Indianapolis if he delivers consistent snaps. For a team sitting at 8-9 and eyeing a competitive rebuild, this is the type of low-risk, low-reward offensive line investment that fills a roster hole without committing real assets; it's functional rather than bold, which is precisely what the CVI grade reflects.