Every NFL player ranked by public sentiment, performance, contract value, and fan votes.
| # | Player | Pos | Team | Sentiment | CVI | Perf▼ | Fan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1901 | Ale Kaho | LB | Washington Commanders | D- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1902 | Ethan Bonner | CB | Miami Dolphins | B | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1903 | Jimmy Horn Jr. | WR | Carolina Panthers | D- | C- | D | N/A |
| 1904 | Kt Leveston | OT | Cleveland Browns | D | C+ | — | N/A |
| 1905 | Caleb Johnson | LB | Miami Dolphins | D+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1906 | Dell Pettus | S | New England Patriots | B | D | D | N/A |
| 1907 | Eric Saubert | TE | Seattle Seahawks | F | C- | D | N/A |
| 1908 | Jalen Davis | CB | Cincinnati Bengals | C+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1909 | T.j. Tampa | CB | Baltimore Ravens | B- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1910 | Ali Gaye | LB | Tennessee Titans | A | C- | D | N/A |
| 1911 | British Brooks | RB | Houston Texans | D | C- | D | N/A |
| 1912 | Brodric Martin-rhodes | DT | Las Vegas Raiders | F | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1913 | Jake Hummel | LB | Houston Texans | D+ | D | D | N/A |
| 1914 | Kain Medrano | LB | Washington Commanders | C+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1915 | Kendell Brooks | S | Tennessee Titans | B- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1916 | Nick Hampton | LB | Carolina Panthers | A | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1917 | Cody White | WR | Seattle Seahawks | C | C- | D | N/A |
| 1918 | Colson Yankoff | TE | Washington Commanders | B | C- | D | N/A |
| 1919 | Demani Richardson | S | Carolina Panthers | D+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1920 | Jamari Thrash | WR | Cleveland Browns | D+ | C- | D | N/A |
| 1921 | Trent Sherfield Sr | WR | New England Patriots | D | C- | D | N/A |
| 1922 | Art Green | CB | New York Giants | D+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1923 | Brian Asamoah Ii | LB | Cincinnati Bengals | D- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1924 | Isaiah Stalbird | LB | New Orleans Saints | D | C- | D | N/A |
| 1925 | Sam Franklin Jr. | S | Buffalo Bills | C+ | D- | D | N/A |
| 1926 | Tim Jones | WR | Jacksonville Jaguars | C- | C- | D | N/A |
| 1927 | Tyrus Wheat | DE | Dallas Cowboys | C | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1928 | Josh Wallace | CB | Los Angeles Rams | B- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1929 | Thomas Incoom | LB | Carolina Panthers | C+ | C- | D | N/A |
| 1930 | Brent Urban | DE | Free Agent | D+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1931 | Bryce Young | QB | Carolina Panthers | F | C | D | N/A |
| 1932 | D.J. Davidson | DT | New York Giants | D- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1933 | Ja’seem Reed | WR | Carolina Panthers | D | C- | D | N/A |
| 1934 | Jerrick Reed Ii | S | Tennessee Titans | D | D | D | N/A |
| 1935 | Kristian Welch | LB | Green Bay Packers | C+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1936 | Tyrone Broden | WR | Seattle Seahawks | C+ | C- | D | N/A |
| 1937 | Jordan Moore | WR | Cincinnati Bengals | D+ | C- | D | N/A |
| 1938 | Karene Reid | LB | Denver Broncos | D+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1939 | Levelle Bailey | LB | Denver Broncos | A+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1940 | Christian Braswell | CB | Jacksonville Jaguars | D | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1941 | Julius Chestnut | RB | Tennessee Titans | D+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1942 | Keandre Lambert-smith | WR | Los Angeles Chargers | C+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1943 | Atonio Mafi | G | Las Vegas Raiders | D | C+ | D | N/A |
| 1944 | Braeden Daniels | OT | Miami Dolphins | D+ | C+ | — | N/A |
| 1945 | Carson Vinson | OT | Baltimore Ravens | B- | C+ | — | N/A |
| 1946 | David Walker | LB | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | F | C+ | D | N/A |
| 1947 | Elijah Roberts | DE | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | B- | C- | D | N/A |
| 1948 | Giovanni Manu | OT | Detroit Lions | D+ | C+ | — | N/A |
| 1949 | Jalen Travis | OT | Indianapolis Colts | D | C+ | — | N/A |
| 1950 | James Proche Ii | WR | Tennessee Titans | C | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1951 | Javon Foster | OT | Cincinnati Bengals | D | C+ | — | N/A |
| 1952 | Markees Watts | LB | Cleveland Browns | D+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1953 | Myron Cunningham | OT | Detroit Lions | D | C+ | — | N/A |
| 1954 | Sam Howell | QB | Dallas Cowboys | C+ | C | D | N/A |
| 1955 | Sedrick Van Pran-granger | C | Buffalo Bills | D | C+ | — | N/A |
| 1956 | Jamal Hill | LB | Houston Texans | D | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1957 | Malik Cunningham | WR | Detroit Lions | D+ | C- | D | N/A |
| 1958 | Xavier Thomas | LB | Houston Texans | C- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1959 | Cameron Goode | LB | Miami Dolphins | D+ | C- | D | N/A |
| 1960 | Khalil Dorsey | CB | Detroit Lions | D+ | D | D | N/A |
| 1961 | Daniel Thomas | S | Cleveland Browns | C | D- | D | N/A |
| 1962 | Darius Cooper | WR | Philadelphia Eagles | A | C- | D | N/A |
| 1963 | DJ Davidson | DT | Washington Commanders | C | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1964 | Marlowe Wax | LB | Los Angeles Chargers | D+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1965 | B.j. Green Ii | DE | Jacksonville Jaguars | B+ | C- | D | N/A |
| 1966 | C.j. Goodwin | CB | Dallas Cowboys | A- | D | D | N/A |
| 1967 | Chaz Chambliss | LB | Minnesota Vikings | C | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1968 | Maason Smith | DT | Jacksonville Jaguars | D- | C- | D | N/A |
| 1969 | John Bullock | LB | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | F | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1970 | Trevor Siemian | QB | Atlanta Falcons | D+ | C | D | N/A |
| 1971 | Austin Keys | LB | Arizona Cardinals | D | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1972 | Kevin Knowles | CB | Kansas City Chiefs | B+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1973 | Xavier Gipson | WR | New York Giants | A | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1974 | Gage Larvadain | WR | Cleveland Browns | D+ | C- | D | N/A |
| 1975 | Ty'ron Hopper | LB | Green Bay Packers | B | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1976 | Dj Ivey | CB | Cincinnati Bengals | C+ | D | D | N/A |
| 1977 | Riley Leonard | QB | Indianapolis Colts | B- | C | D | N/A |
| 1978 | Lequint Allen Jr. | RB | Jacksonville Jaguars | B- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1979 | Zacch Pickens | DT | Kansas City Chiefs | F | C- | D | N/A |
| 1980 | Channing Tindall | LB | Atlanta Falcons | C+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1981 | James Hudson | OT | New England Patriots | B- | C+ | — | N/A |
| 1982 | Marshall Lang | TE | Minnesota Vikings | C- | C- | D | N/A |
| 1983 | David Martin-robinson | TE | Tennessee Titans | B- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1984 | Josh Blackwell | CB | Chicago Bears | B | D- | D | N/A |
| 1985 | Kalia Davis | DT | Cleveland Browns | B | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1986 | Ulysses Bentley Iv | RB | Indianapolis Colts | B | C- | D | N/A |
| 1987 | Aeneas Peebles | DT | Baltimore Ravens | C+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1988 | Cj Okoye | DT | Baltimore Ravens | B- | C- | D | N/A |
| 1989 | Jack Cochrane | LB | Kansas City Chiefs | B | D | D | N/A |
| 1990 | Tremon Smith | CB | Houston Texans | B- | D- | D | N/A |
| 1991 | Erik Ezukanma | WR | Philadelphia Eagles | C- | — | D | N/A |
| 1992 | Ja'lynn Polk | WR | New Orleans Saints | D- | D | D | N/A |
| 1993 | Smael Mondon Jr. | LB | Philadelphia Eagles | D | D+ | D | N/A |
| 1994 | Austin Trammell | WR | Jacksonville Jaguars | C- | C- | D | N/A |
| 1995 | Amari Gainer | LB | New England Patriots | C+ | D | D | N/A |
| 1996 | Dare Ogunbowale | RB | Free Agent | C | D- | D | N/A |
| 1997 | Elijah Simmons | DT | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | D+ | C- | D | N/A |
| 1998 | Kendall Williamson | S | Los Angeles Chargers | D | D | D | N/A |
| 1999 | Khristian Boyd | DT | New Orleans Saints | D | C- | D | N/A |
| 2000 | Warren Brinson | DT | Green Bay Packers | D | D+ | D | N/A |