Every NFL player ranked by public sentiment, performance, contract value, and fan votes.
| # | Player | Pos | Team | Sentiment | CVI | Perf▼ | Fan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1901 |  Dominick Puni | G | San Francisco 49ers | A | B- | F | — |
| 1902 |  Dylan Laube | RB | Las Vegas Raiders | D | B- | F |
— |
| 1903 |  Hakeem Adeniji | OT | Free Agent | — | C | — | — |
| 1904 |  Isaiah Davis | RB | New York Jets | D- | B- | F | — |
| 1905 |  Isaiah Hodgins | WR | New York Giants | C | C | F | — |
| 1906 |  Jalen Tolbert | WR | Miami Dolphins | C | B- | F | — |
| 1907 |  Javon Solomon | DE | Buffalo Bills | B | B- | F | — |
| 1908 |  Jeremiah Trotter Jr. | LB | Philadelphia Eagles | — | B- | F | — |
| 1909 |  Jeremy Mcnichols | RB | Washington Commanders | B- | C | F | — |
| 1910 |  Jessie Bates | S | Detroit Lions | B- | B- | F | — |
| 1911 |  Jordan Whittington | WR | Los Angeles Rams | — | B- | F | — |
| 1912 |  Josh Wallace | CB | Los Angeles Rams | — | B+ | F | — |
| 1913 |  Kitan Oladapo | S | Green Bay Packers | — | B- | F | — |
| 1914 |  Kt Leveston | OT | Cleveland Browns | D | B- | — | — |
| 1915 |  Lajohntay Wester | WR | Baltimore Ravens | C | B- | F | — |
| 1916 |  Logan Hall | DE | Houston Texans | B+ | C | F | — |
| 1917 |  Lucas Niang | OT | Washington Commanders | — | B- | — | — |
| 1918 |  Malik Washington | WR | Miami Dolphins | — | B- | F | — |
| 1919 |  Marco Wilson | CB | Miami Dolphins | C | B- | F | — |
| 1920 |  Marquez Valdes-scantling | WR | Pittsburgh Steelers | B- | B- | F | — |
| 1921 |  Mason Mccormick | G | Pittsburgh Steelers | B- | B- | F | — |
| 1922 |  Matt Goncalves | G | Indianapolis Colts | — | B- | F | — |
| 1923 |  Patrick Paul | OT | Miami Dolphins | — | B- | — | — |
| 1924 |  Pierre Strong Jr. | RB | Green Bay Packers | C | C- | F | — |
| 1925 |  Sione Vaki | RB | Detroit Lions | — | B- | F | — |
| 1926 |  Tanner Hudson | TE | Cincinnati Bengals | B- | D+ | F | — |
| 1927 |  Tanor Bortolini | C | Indianapolis Colts | — | B- | — | — |
| 1928 |  Taven Bryan | DT | Baltimore Ravens | — | B- | F | — |
| 1929 |  Terrace Marshall Jr. | WR | Miami Dolphins | — | B+ | F | — |
| 1930 |  Thomas Incoom | LB | Carolina Panthers | C- | C- | F | — |
| 1931 |  Treylon Burks | WR | Washington Commanders | B- | C | F | — |
| 1932 |  Troy Reeder | LB | Free Agent | — | C | F | — |
| 1933 |  Ty'ron Hopper | LB | Green Bay Packers | — | B- | F | — |
| 1934 |  Tyler Davis | DE | Los Angeles Rams | A- | B- | F | — |
| 1935 |  Will Dissly | TE | Los Angeles Chargers | F | B- | F | — |
| 1936 |  Will Shipley | RB | Philadelphia Eagles | D | B- | F | — |
| 1937 |  Yasir Abdullah | LB | Jacksonville Jaguars | D | B- | F | — |
| 1938 |  Zach Frazier | C | Pittsburgh Steelers | — | B- | — | — |
| 1939 |  Adam Trautman | TE | Denver Broncos | — | D+ | F | — |
| 1940 |  Benito Jones | DT | Miami Dolphins | — | B- | F | — |
| 1941 |  Brayden Willis | TE | San Francisco 49ers | — | B- | F | — |
| 1942 | C C.J. Goodwin | CB | Free Agent | D | C | F | — |
| 1943 |  Cameron Mitchell | CB | Indianapolis Colts | D | B- | F | — |
| 1944 |  Chris Lammons | CB | Indianapolis Colts | — | B- | F | — |
| 1945 |  Dameon Pierce | RB | Philadelphia Eagles | B- | C+ | F | — |
| 1946 |  Darian Kinnard | OT | Green Bay Packers | — | C | — | — |
| 1947 |  Darrell Luter Jr. | CB | San Francisco 49ers | D+ | B- | F | — |
| 1948 |  Darren Hall | CB | Free Agent | D | C- | F | — |
| 1949 |  David Moore | WR | Carolina Panthers | C- | B- | F | — |
| 1950 |  Garret Wallow | LB | San Francisco 49ers | B- | C+ | F | — |
| 1951 |  Jalen Reeves-Maybin | LB | Chicago Bears | B | B+ | F | — |
| 1952 |  Jammie Robinson | S | Atlanta Falcons | — | B- | F | — |
| 1953 |  Jerry Tillery | DT | Indianapolis Colts | D+ | B- | F | — |
| 1954 |  Jl Skinner | S | Denver Broncos | B | B- | F | — |
| 1955 |  Jonah Williams | DE | Arizona Cardinals | C | B- | F | — |
| 1956 |  Josh Woods | LB | Atlanta Falcons | C+ | B- | F | — |
| 1957 |  Joshua Uche | LB | Miami Dolphins | — | B- | F | — |
| 1958 |  Kavontae Turpin | WR | Dallas Cowboys | B- | C- | F | — |
| 1959 |  Kion Smith | G | Miami Dolphins | D+ | C+ | F | — |
| 1960 |  Labryan Ray | DE | Carolina Panthers | C+ | B- | F | — |
| 1961 |  Lonnie Johnson Jr. | S | Miami Dolphins | B- | B+ | F | — |
| 1962 |  Michael Clemons | DE | Indianapolis Colts | A- | C+ | F | — |
| 1963 | Micheal Clemons | DE | Indianapolis Colts | B- | C | F | — |
| 1964 |  Nick Niemann | LB | Green Bay Packers | — | B- | F | — |
| 1965 |  Owen Pappoe | LB | Arizona Cardinals | — | B- | F | — |
| 1966 |  Patrick Taylor Jr. | RB | San Francisco 49ers | D | C | F | — |
| 1967 |  Sam Webb | CB | Cleveland Browns | — | B- | F | — |
| 1968 |  Tyler Lockett | WR | Free Agent | B | C | F | — |
| 1969 |  Austin Johnson | DT | Free Agent | — | C- | F | — |
| 1970 |  Ben Bartch | G | Detroit Lions | D+ | B- | F | — |
| 1971 |  Brett Toth | C | San Francisco 49ers | — | C+ | — | — |
| 1972 |  Buddy Johnson | LB | Free Agent | — | C- | F | — |
| 1973 |  Darnell Washington | TE | Pittsburgh Steelers | B+ | B- | F | — |
| 1974 |  Dee Eskridge | WR | Miami Dolphins | — | B- | F | — |
| 1975 |  Elijah Hicks | S | Chicago Bears | A | C | F | — |
| 1976 |  Greg Gaines | DT | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | D+ | C- | F | — |
| 1977 |  Isaiah Simmons | LB | Carolina Panthers | A- | B+ | F | — |
| 1978 |  Isaiahh Loudermilk | DT | Pittsburgh Steelers | — | B- | F | — |
| 1979 |  Ja'Tyre Carter | G | Carolina Panthers | D+ | B- | F | — |
| 1980 |  Jerome Ford | RB | Washington Commanders | B- | B- | F | — |
| 1981 |  Jihad Ward | LB | Tennessee Titans | — | B- | F | — |
| 1982 |  Joey Blount | S | Arizona Cardinals | — | B- | F | — |
| 1983 |  Josh Whyle | TE | Green Bay Packers | B | B- | F | — |
| 1984 |  K.j. Britt | LB | New England Patriots | D+ | B- | F | — |
| 1985 |  Kei'trel Clark | CB | Arizona Cardinals | D | B- | F | — |
| 1986 |  Marvin Mims Jr. | WR | Denver Broncos | — | B- | F | — |
| 1987 |  Max Scharping | G | Pittsburgh Steelers | — | B- | F | — |
| 1988 |  Miles Sanders | RB | Dallas Cowboys | — | B- | F | — |
| 1989 |  Nick Zakelj | OT | San Francisco 49ers | D+ | C+ | — | — |
| 1990 |  Saahdiq Charles | G | Carolina Panthers | D+ | D+ | F | — |
| 1991 |  Sean Tucker | RB | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | A | C | F | — |
| 1992 |  Tyjae Spears | RB | Tennessee Titans | — | B- | F | — |
| 1993 |  Tyler Scott | WR | Los Angeles Rams | — | B- | F | — |
| 1994 |  Von Miller | LB | Washington Commanders | B | B- | F | — |
| 1995 |  Blake Freeland | OT | Indianapolis Colts | — | C+ | — | — |
| 1996 |  Brandon Pili | DT | Seattle Seahawks | B- | B- | F | — |
| 1997 |  Cam Sample | DE | San Francisco 49ers | D- | B- | F | — |
| 1998 |  Chris Williams | DT | Atlanta Falcons | D+ | C | F | — |
| 1999 |  Dawand Jones | OT | Cleveland Browns | — | C+ | — | — |
| 2000 |  Jaleel Mclaughlin | RB | Denver Broncos | C- | A- | F | — |