Taylor Moton

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

This Taylor Moton extension earns a brutal F CVI, representing a significant overpay for a tackle who's trending in the wrong direction. At $22M AAV, Carolina is paying Moton like an elite franchise cornerstone, but his recent performance suggests he's closer to a middling starter who's lost a step from his 2020-2021 peak. The 29-year-old right tackle is entering the twilight phase for his position, making this two-year commitment particularly risky given the lack of upside in his trajectory. While the $36.8M guaranteed provides Carolina with roster flexibility after 2025, they're essentially betting $22M per year that Moton can recapture form that's been slipping for multiple seasons. The Panthers have handcuffed themselves to an aging, overpaid tackle when they could have allocated this money toward rebuilding their offensive line with younger, more cost-effective options. This deal screams of a front office clinging to past production rather than making the hard decisions necessary for sustainable roster construction.

Performance Analysis

Taylor Moton's F grade in Carolina is one of the most striking anomalies in the system for a tackle who has been one of the Panthers' most consistent offensive linemen for years. Moton has been a reliable right tackle in an otherwise dysfunctional offensive line, providing solid pass protection and run blocking year after year. The F grade is almost certainly a data issue rather than a reflection of his actual on-field performance. Carolina's offense has counted on Moton as one of the few bright spots up front, and the tape supports a much higher evaluation. His professionalism and consistency have been a stabilizing force for a franchise that has struggled mightily. This grade should be disregarded in favor of what the eye test clearly shows.