Josh Sills

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

Josh Sills' one-year, $1.1M deal with the Indianapolis Colts earns a solid B- CVI, representing a fair value signing for organizational depth. At just over league minimum, the Colts are paying appropriate market rate for a depth piece who can step in when needed without breaking the bank. The 25-year-old guard brings developmental upside on a prove-it contract that carries virtually zero financial risk for Indianapolis. This type of low-commitment deal allows the Colts to evaluate Sills' potential while maintaining salary cap flexibility, with the option to either re-sign him at a modest raise or move on without any dead money complications. For a team looking to solidify their interior line depth without major investment, this represents shrewd roster management that addresses a need without overcommitting resources to a player still establishing his NFL credentials.

Performance Analysis

Josh Sills earns an F grade as a guard who has struggled to establish himself as a viable starter with the Colts. Indianapolis' offensive line needs has been a persistent problem, and Sills hasn't been part of the solution despite getting opportunities. His play in the interior has been below the standard needed to protect the quarterback and create running lanes consistently. The Colts are likely looking for upgrades at the position, which puts Sills' roster spot in jeopardy heading into the next cycle. He's a replacement-level interior lineman without a clear path to a starting role.