Hunter Wohler

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

Hunter Wohler's four-year, $4.3M deal with Indianapolis earns a C+ CVI, representing a fair market deal for a developmental safety with limited NFL track record. At $1.1M annually with minimal guaranteed money ($0.1M), the Colts are making a low-risk investment in a player who projects as a depth piece rather than an immediate starter. The contract structure heavily favors Indianapolis, giving them the flexibility to evaluate Wohler over multiple seasons without significant financial commitment if he doesn't develop as expected. While Wohler lacks the proven production to command premium safety money, his youth and athleticism provide enough upside to justify this modest investment. This type of deal reflects smart roster building — the Colts can afford to be patient with his development while maintaining cap flexibility, though they'll need Wohler to quickly establish himself as more than a special teams contributor to maximize the value. The contract positions him as organizational depth with hopes he can eventually grow into a reliable backup or situational starter.

Performance Analysis

Hunter Wohler is a replacement-level safety at this stage of his young career, earning a D- performance grade that reflects the extremely limited sample size and production his rookie season has generated so far. Through two games, he has recorded 11 tackles — a modest but not insignificant number for someone operating in what appears to be a depth role — and that tackle production represents the entirety of his statistical footprint through this early stretch of his career. The core weakness here is straightforward: two games played is simply not enough to establish any meaningful presence in the lineup, and his invisibility in the stat sheet beyond that tackle total suggests he has not yet forced his way into expanded responsibilities. At 23 years old and drafted in the seventh round with the 232nd overall pick, Wohler was never projected as a cornerstone defensive asset, and his $1.1M rookie scale contract reflects the organizational calculus of a depth or developmental player rather than a projected starter. The Indianapolis secondary has seen notable additions in recent months — Nasir Adderley and Cam Taylor-Britt among them — which further crowds the depth chart and narrows the path toward consistent snaps. The media landscape around Wohler is essentially silent, with no extension discussions, no performance accolades, and no controversy to speak of, which for a seventh-round rookie in this situation reads as organizational neutrality rather than genuine optimism. With the regular season still 134 days away, there is time for a training camp breakout to change the narrative, but nothing in the current data suggests the Colts are building meaningful plans around him.