Harrison Butker

Career StatsC+

Year	Team	GP	FG%
Career		59	88.4%
2025		17	86.8%
2024		13	84.0%
2023		17	94.3%
2022		13	75.0%
2021

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

The Chiefs locked up a solid starter at kicker with what amounts to a fair deal that slightly favors Kansas City. Butker's $6.4M AAV represents premium money for the position, but his consistent production as a reliable leg in high-pressure situations — including multiple playoff runs and Super Bowl appearances — justifies the investment for a franchise prioritizing championship windows. At 29, he's entering his prime years for a kicker, where leg strength typically remains elite while experience peaks, making this four-year commitment well-timed rather than a declining asset gamble. The $17.8M guaranteed over the first portion of the deal provides Butker with meaningful security while giving Kansas City flexibility to move on if performance drops, a crucial hedge given how quickly kickers can lose accuracy. This B CVI reflects a franchise that understands special teams matter in January — they're paying market rate for proven clutch performance rather than gambling on cheaper alternatives when every point counts toward another Lombardi Trophy.

Performance Analysis

Harrison Butker is a nine-year veteran placekicker for the Kansas City Chiefs and one of the most decorated specialists of his generation. Earning a C+ overall grade this season, Butker remains a reliable weapon for Kansas City despite operating below his own lofty standards. His career body of work far outpaces this current snapshot, and context matters enormously when evaluating a kicker of his pedigree. At 86.8% field goal accuracy this season, Butker sits just above the NFL average of 85.0%, though well short of the elite threshold of 93.0%. That gap from elite is the primary concern — a kicker of Butker's caliber is expected to push that upper tier, not hover near league average. His recent season trend tells a complicated story: after an A+ campaign in 2023, he slipped to a D+ in 2024 before partially recovering to a C in 2025, suggesting inconsistency has crept into his game. The 2023 season reminds evaluators what Butker's ceiling looks like — a true difference-maker capable of flipping field position battles and closing out tight games. If he can rebuild mechanical consistency and recapture that elite accuracy, he remains one of the AFC's most valuable specialists. The Chiefs will monitor his trajectory closely entering what could be a pivotal stretch of his career.

Current Sentiment

Harrison Butker enters the 2026 season under a cloud of uncertainty, with at least one prominent media narrative openly questioning whether his tenure with the Kansas City Chiefs is nearing its end. Despite his decorated championship résumé and a contract reflecting his historical value to the franchise, the perception landscape heading into OTAs is notably more skeptical than in prior years. Coverage has taken on a slightly sardonic tone, with observers noting a shaky field goal that required an upright bounce and even poking fun at his appearance at voluntary workouts — neither of which projects the image of an unquestioned starter. On the positive side, Butker did show up to OTAs and contributed scoring plays, suggesting he remains in the mix and is engaged with the team's offseason program. Overall, the media narrative reflects a player at a crossroads — still respected for his past accomplishments but facing legitimate questions about reliability and long-term roster security that will define how the 2026 season unfolds.