Evan Neal

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

This signing grades out as a slight overpay for the New York Giants — the team is getting approximately what they're paying for in on-field production. Evan's on-field performance ranks in the bottom quartile among NFL OTs, grading him as an unproven at the position. His $1.2M average annual value ranks as bargain money for the OT market. The production lines up closely with the price tag — unproven production at bargain money, which is essentially paying fair market value. Evan is squarely in his prime, which adds to the deal's upside — the team should get multiple productive seasons out of this contract. The 1-year, $1.2M deal keeps the commitment short, giving the team financial flexibility to move on if performance drops.

Performance Analysis

Evan Neal's F grade is a brutal indictment of a former top-10 pick who has been unable to stay on the field or live up to his draft pedigree. The seventh overall selection in 2022 has played just 13 games across four seasons with the Giants, including only two appearances in 2025. Injuries have completely derailed what was supposed to be a franchise-altering investment at offensive tackle, and the Giants have gotten almost nothing in return for that premium draft capital. When he has played, Neal has not shown the dominant traits that made him a top prospect out of Alabama. This is shaping up to be one of the most disappointing first-round picks in recent Giants history, and at this point, New York would be wise to move on and cut their losses.

Fan Sentiment

A low-risk, high-upside retention bet on a former top-7 pick trying to salvage his career. Multiple headlines highlight Neal's deliberate choice to stay and rebuild his reputation in New York. The key signal is Neal's apparent renewed commitment after two disappointing, injury-plagued seasons. Fans are cautiously optimistic but split — many remember the flashes alongside the frustrating inconsistency. If Neal finally stays healthy, the Giants land a quality starter at below-market value.