D.j. Humphries

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

This D.J. Humphries deal represents a significant overpay for an unproven commodity, earning a disappointing D- CVI despite the relatively modest $2.5M AAV price tag. While that salary might seem reasonable for offensive tackle help, Humphries' unproven performance tier makes this a puzzling allocation of resources — even replacement-level tackles typically command similar money, meaning there's little upside here relative to the risk. The veteran's injury history and inconsistent play over recent seasons suggest a player whose best days are likely behind him, making this feel more like a desperation move than strategic roster building. The heavy guarantee structure ($2.3M of $2.5M total) compounds the problem by offering minimal flexibility if Humphries fails to deliver adequate protection. For a team investing in offensive line help, this contract represents poor value hunting — the type of deal that looks questionable on paper and rarely exceeds expectations on the field.

Contracts in the Same Value Band

Other same-position deals the Contract Value Index also places in the D band — a quick read on where D.j.'s contract sits relative to comparable money.

Performance Analysis

D.J. Humphries is an 11-year veteran offensive tackle whose career has been defined as much by his considerable physical tools and draft pedigree — a first-round selection out of Florida in 2015 — as by the durability questions that have followed him throughout his time in the league. With just 20 career games to his name across 11 seasons, Humphries falls well short of the threshold that typically defines even a developing starter at the position, making availability the central storyline of his professional journey rather than any question of talent or technique. For an offensive tackle, where sustained presence and continuity along the line are paramount to a team's identity and success, that limited on-field footprint represents a significant concern for any franchise considering his services. When healthy, Humphries has flashed the athleticism and length that made him a coveted prospect, and teams understand that a left tackle with his physical profile doesn't grow on trees, particularly in a free agent market that rarely offers former first-rounders. Now 32 and entering the back half of what has been a frustratingly interrupted career, the conversation around Humphries shifts from potential to pragmatism — can he stay on the field long enough to provide meaningful value as a starter or high-upside depth piece? Any team that invests in him will be doing so on a prove-it basis, with an eye toward durability above all else. If he can string together consistent availability in 2025, it would represent the most compelling chapter of a career that has never quite lived up to its promising beginnings.

How D.j. Compares at the Position

D.j. Humphries ranks 1st of 189 graded offensive tackles by performance. D.j. grades out ahead of names like Jc Latham (B).

Peers ranked by Performance grade among players at the same position. Tap any name for their full profile.

Current Sentiment

D.J. Humphries enters 2026 as a journeyman offensive tackle with a modest veteran profile—11 years of experience but no Pro Bowl or All-Pro recognition, currently on a $2.5M deal reflecting his role-player status. Recent headlines position him as a reliable depth option and injury replacement, with the Rams signing him to address Alaric Jackson's blood clot situation and other teams (49ers, Bears) considering him as a contingency plan. Media coverage is neutral-to-functional rather than enthusiastic, treating Humphries as a capable stopgap rather than a solution to franchise tackle problems. His perception benefits from consistent employment and team interest, but lacks the accolades or standout performance metrics that would elevate him beyond a solid backup narrative. Overall, Humphries is perceived as a dependable veteran reserve—useful in a pinch, but not a marquee free-agent signing or long-term starter in the eyes of analysts and fans.