D.j. Humphries

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

This D.J. Humphries deal represents a significant overpay for an unproven commodity, earning a disappointing D- CVI despite the relatively modest $2.5M AAV price tag. While that salary might seem reasonable for offensive tackle help, Humphries' unproven performance tier makes this a puzzling allocation of resources — even replacement-level tackles typically command similar money, meaning there's little upside here relative to the risk. The veteran's injury history and inconsistent play over recent seasons suggest a player whose best days are likely behind him, making this feel more like a desperation move than strategic roster building. The heavy guarantee structure ($2.3M of $2.5M total) compounds the problem by offering minimal flexibility if Humphries fails to deliver adequate protection. For a team investing in offensive line help, this contract represents poor value hunting — the type of deal that looks questionable on paper and rarely exceeds expectations on the field.

Performance Analysis

D.J. Humphries earns an F as a free agent offensive tackle, a former long-time Cardinals starter whose career has been derailed by knee injuries. Humphries was once a solid left tackle who protected the blind side capably in Arizona for years. But the injuries have taken their toll, and he has been unable to stay healthy enough to attract interest on the open market. His declining play when available has compounded the health concerns. Humphries gave Arizona productive years, but the current version of him is no longer a viable NFL starter.