Colton Mckivitz

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

Spotrac flags Colton McKivitz's contract as a market-rate deal; FanVerdicts grades it C+ Contract Value Index because the production-to-pay ratio shakes out accordingly. McKivitz carried a modest workload in the 2025 season—3 tackles across 17 games—which underscores his role as a positional anchor rather than a high-impact edge-setter, a gap the C+ CVI reflects in its assessment of a $15M AAV commitment over three years. The right tackle market rewards stability and scheme fit over splash plays, and at 29 years old in his sixth professional season, McKivitz delivers exactly that: he's a solid starter whose reliable, low-drama tenure has earned organizational trust, evidenced by the 49ers' willingness to extend him despite opportunities to test free agency elsewhere. The sentiment around him remains firmly in the A- range—media framing emphasizes his standing as a cornerstone of San Francisco's offensive infrastructure and his inclusion in recent top-100 player rankings—yet the steady F performance grade and pedestrian tackle totals reveal the contract is priced for a dependable journeyman, not a premium talent commanding top-five positional money. With three years of runway at his current AAV, McKivitz represents a manageable financial commitment aligned with his ceiling: a professional, injury-resistant starter who won't break the bank but also won't elevate the offense through elite play. The CVI grade acknowledges that trade-off fairly—he's getting paid like a quality backup-to-starter hybrid at a premium position, which is neither a steal nor an overpay in an offseason landscape where the 49ers are clearly prioritizing continuity up front.

Contracts in the Same Value Band

Other same-position deals the Contract Value Index also places in the C band — a quick read on where Colton's contract sits relative to comparable money.

Performance Analysis

Colton McKivitz is a six-year veteran offensive tackle with the San Francisco 49ers, having appeared in 31 career games across his tenure. The 29-year-old represents a steady, experienced depth piece in San Francisco's offensive line rotation. McKivitz earns a B+ performance grade, reflecting reliable availability and professional-level execution in his current role. McKivitz's standout metric this season is his exceptional snap availability, posting a 99.4 percent rate against the NFL average of 72.0 percent. His durability and consistent presence at tackle represent genuine value in an era where offensive line injuries frequently derail team chemistry and protection schemes. However, limited granular performance data makes deeper technical analysis difficult; his B+ grade suggests competent play without elite-level dominance at the position. As a veteran reserve, McKivitz fills a crucial roster function for contending rosters like San Francisco's. His ability to stay healthy and ready for immediate deployment—whether due to injury or game plan necessity—matters in December and January football. The Niners can count on him to provide professional-level snaps without significant regression. Moving forward, McKivitz's trajectory likely remains as a reliable backup and potential starter in short-term situations rather than an ascending contributor. At 29 with six seasons of experience, he has established his floor as a serviceable tackle capable of filling gaps competently. Monitor whether San Francisco invests in longer-term offensive line depth in upcoming offseasons, which could signal confidence in McKivitz's role or suggest organizational plans to upgrade the position.

How Colton Compares at the Position

Colton Mckivitz ranks 1st of 189 graded offensive tackles by performance. Colton grades out ahead of names like Jordan Mailata (B).

Peers ranked by Performance grade among players at the same position. Tap any name for their full profile.

Current Sentiment

Colton McKivitz enters 2026 as a reliable veteran offensive lineman whose perception is anchored by his status as a multi-year starter on a mid-tier contract, without Pro Bowl or All-Pro recognition. Recent media coverage has been notably positive, with McKivitz publicly expressing commitment to a long-term future with San Francisco and confidence in the 49ers' offensive line trajectory—messaging that reinforces organizational stability rather than suggesting elite performance. The five-headline cluster emphasizes his desire to remain a 49er beyond 2028 and his belief in the unit's improvement, which counters any narrative of decline or organizational uncertainty. Fan and media perception reflects cautious optimism: McKivitz is viewed as a competent, durable starter whose longevity and team loyalty are assets, but without standout accolades, he remains a solid contributor rather than a marquee name. Overall, McKivitz's perception sits in the upper-middle tier for a veteran lineman—respected for consistency and commitment, but not generating the buzz of an ascending star or All-Pro candidate.