MLB Player Rankings 2026

#	Player	Pos	Team	Perf	CVI	Sentiment	Fan
1	Dominic Smith	1B	Braves	B+ Top 20%	A Top 9%	C+ Top 48% — above average	N/A
2	Jonathan Aranda	1B	Rays	B+ Top 20%	N/A	D+ Bottom 30%	N/A
3	Pavin Smith	1B	Diamondbacks	B+ Top 20%	A Top 9%	D- Bottom 12%	N/A
4	Ben Rice	1B	Yankees	B+ Top 20%	N/A	C+ Top 48% — above average	N/A
5	Jared Young	1B	Mets	B+ Top 20%	N/A	D- Bottom 12%	N/A
6	Patrick Wisdom	1B	Mariners	B+ Top 20%	N/A	F Bottom 5%	N/A
7	Blaze Jordan	1B	Cardinals	B+ Top 20%	N/A	D+ Bottom 30%	N/A
8	Joey Meneses	1B	Athletics	B+ Top 20%	N/A	B- Top 38%	N/A
9	Ty France	1B	Padres	B+ Top 20%	A Top 9%	C- Below average	N/A
10	Buddy Kennedy	1B	Giants	B+ Top 20%	N/A	D+ Bottom 30%	N/A
11	Ildemaro Vargas	1B	Diamondbacks	B Top 29%	N/A	D+ Bottom 30%	N/A
12	Yandy Diaz	1B	Rays	B Top 29%	B- Top 38%	A Top 9%	N/A
13	David Fry	1B	Guardians	B Top 29%	A- Top 13%	C+ Top 48% — above average	N/A
14	Alec Burleson	1B	Cardinals	B Top 29%	B+ Top 20%	B+ Top 20%	N/A
15	Willson Contreras	1B	Red Sox	B Top 29%	C Around average	B+ Top 20%	N/A
16	Paul Goldschmidt	1B	Yankees	B- Top 38%	B- Top 38%	A+ Top 3%	N/A
17	Jake Bauers	1B	Brewers	B- Top 38%	B+ Top 20%	C- Below average	N/A
18	Curtis Mead	1B	Nationals	B- Top 38%	N/A	D+ Bottom 30%	N/A
19	Kyle Manzardo	1B	Guardians	B- Top 38%	N/A	B- Top 38%	N/A
20	Ryan O'Hearn	1B	Pirates	B- Top 38%	C Around average	B Top 29%	N/A