FanVerdicts
NFLNBAMLB
FanVerdicts
TransactionsPlayersTeamsGMsDraftTrade ValuesLiveScoresArticles
Sign In

FanVerdicts

Where fans deliver the verdict on every move in professional sports.

NFL

  • Transactions
  • Player Rankings
  • Teams
  • GM Rankings
  • Draft
  • Scores
  • Standings

NBA

  • Transactions
  • Player Rankings
  • Teams
  • GM Rankings
  • Draft
  • Scores
  • Standings

MLB

  • Transactions
  • Player Rankings
  • Teams
  • GM Rankings
  • Draft
  • Scores
  • Standings

Company

  • About
  • Methodology
  • Insights
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Key Dates

Follow

  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
© 2026 FanVerdicts. All rights reserved. Not affiliated with the NFL or any professional sports league.
Feedback

MLB Player Rankings 2026

Every MLB player ranked by public sentiment, performance, contract value, and fan votes.

MLB/Player Rankings
Player RankingsFree Agents
PerformanceCVISentimentFan Verdict
AllSPRPC1B2B3BSSLFCFRFDH
↑ Worst First
ABCDF
#PlayerPosTeamPerfCVISentimentFan
98Michael PetersenMichael PetersenRPMarlins
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
97Nathan ChurchNathan ChurchLFCardinals
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
B
Top 29%
—
96Owen Caissie
FirstPrevious1234567NextLast251-300 of 348
Owen Caissie
RF
Marlins
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
B+
Top 20%
—
95Peyton PallettePeyton PalletteRPGuardians
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
B-
Top 38%
—
94Ryan BlissRyan Bliss2BMariners
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
F
Bottom 5%
—
93Ryan WatsonRyan WatsonRPRed Sox
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C-
Below average
—
92Ryan WeissRyan WeissRPAstros
C+
Top 48% — above average
C
Around average
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
91Ryan ZeferjahnRyan ZeferjahnRPAngels
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D-
Bottom 12%
—
90Tomoyuki SuganoTomoyuki SuganoSPRockies
C+
Top 48% — above average
C-
Below average
B-
Top 38%
—
89Tristan PetersTristan PetersLFWhite Sox
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
88Troy JohnstonTroy JohnstonOFRockies
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C-
Below average
—
87Tyler TolbertTyler Tolbert2BRoyals
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D+
Bottom 30%
—
86Walbert UrenaWalbert UrenaSPAngels
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
85Will WarrenWill WarrenSPYankees
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
84Zak KentZak KentRPNationals
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D+
Bottom 30%
—
83Brady SingerBrady SingerSPReds
C+
Top 48% — above average
C-
Below average
C-
Below average
—
82Cedric MullinsCedric MullinsCFRays
C+
Top 48% — above average
C+
Top 48% — above average
C-
Below average
—
81Colby ThomasColby ThomasRFAthletics
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
80Curtis MeadCurtis Mead1BNationals
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C
Around average
—
79George KlassenGeorge KlassenSPAngels
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
B-
Top 38%
—
78Hao-yu LEEHao-yu LEE2BTigers
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
A-
Top 13%
—
77Jameson TaillonJameson TaillonSPCubs
C+
Top 48% — above average
D+
Bottom 30%
D-
Bottom 12%
—
76Matthew BoydMatthew BoydSPCubs
C+
Top 48% — above average
C-
Below average
F
Bottom 5%
—
75Mickey MoniakMickey MoniakRFRockies
C+
Top 48% — above average
C+
Top 48% — above average
D+
Bottom 30%
—
74Noelvi MarteNoelvi MarteOFReds
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C-
Below average
—
73Rolddy MunozRolddy MunozRPBraves
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
B-
Top 38%
—
72Sean ManaeaSean ManaeaSPMets
C+
Top 48% — above average
F
Bottom 5%
D+
Bottom 30%
—
71Tim HerrinTim HerrinRPGuardians
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
70Victor VodnikVictor VodnikRPRockies
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
A
Top 9%
—
69Aaron NolaAaron NolaSPPhillies
C+
Top 48% — above average
D+
Bottom 30%
B+
Top 20%
—
68Ben CaspariusBen CaspariusRPDodgers
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D+
Bottom 30%
—
67Bradgley RodriguezBradgley RodriguezSPPadres
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
B+
Top 20%
—
66Brendan DonovanBrendan Donovan2BMariners
C+
Top 48% — above average
C+
Top 48% — above average
A
Top 9%
—
65Cam SchlittlerCam SchlittlerSPYankees
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
A+
Top 3%
—
64Carlos CortesCarlos CortesLFAthletics
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
63Chad PatrickChad PatrickSPBrewers
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
62Colin ReaColin ReaSPCubs
C+
Top 48% — above average
C
Around average
B-
Top 38%
—
61Colt KeithColt Keith2BTigers
C+
Top 48% — above average
C+
Top 48% — above average
B
Top 29%
—
60Dustin HarrisDustin HarrisLFAstros
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D
Bottom 20%
—
59Elvis AlvaradoElvis AlvaradoRPAthletics
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
B
Top 29%
—
58Eric OrzeEric OrzeRPTwins
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
57Francisco AlvarezFrancisco AlvarezCMets
C+
Top 48% — above average
B-
Top 38%
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
56Gabriel MorenoGabriel MorenoCDiamondbacks
C+
Top 48% — above average
B-
Top 38%
D-
Bottom 12%
—
55Gus VarlandGus VarlandRPNationals
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
D-
Bottom 12%
—
54Ian SeymourIan SeymourRPRays
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C
Around average
—
53Joel PayampsJoel PayampsRPBraves
C+
Top 48% — above average
C+
Top 48% — above average
B
Top 29%
—
52Juan MorilloJuan MorilloRPDiamondbacks
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
51Kazuma OkamotoKazuma Okamoto3BBlue Jays
C+
Top 48% — above average
C-
Below average
D+
Bottom 30%
—
50Kerry CarpenterKerry CarpenterRFTigers
C+
Top 48% — above average
C+
Top 48% — above average
C
Around average
—
49Kyle HarrisonKyle HarrisonRPBrewers
C+
Top 48% — above average
—
C+
Top 48% — above average
—