Josh Fleming

Fan & Media Sentiment

Josh Fleming's selection to the Blue Jays' 40-man roster earned a B- CVI, reflecting the tepid but fundamentally positive reception surrounding this organizational depth move. The left-handed reliever's contract choice generated coverage that reads more like roster accounting than player evaluation, with headlines focusing on the mechanics of his selection over Ryan Voth rather than Fleming's upside or potential impact. Baseball analysts approached the move with measured neutrality, breaking down his minor league numbers and role projection without the enthusiasm typically reserved for impact acquisitions or the concern that follows questionable signings. The modest positive sentiment stems largely from the organizational vote of confidence implied by his roster protection, suggesting the Blue Jays see something worthwhile in the 27-year-old's arsenal. While Fleming's CVI reflects steady competence rather than excitement, the lack of criticism or skepticism indicates he's viewed as a sensible depth piece who could provide adequate middle relief innings if called upon.