BP
Buster Posey
President of Baseball Operations since Oct 2024(1 year, 7 mo)
GM rankings — every move graded by sentiment and fan votes.
F
D+
—
Fan Verdict
Grade this GM::
Should Buster Posey be kept, fired, or extended?
47
Transactions
47
Graded
0
Fan Votes
1 year
Tenure
Transaction Breakdown
15
Positive
28
Mixed
4
Negative
League Comparison
#20
Sentiment Rank
of 30 GMs
#22
Most Active
47 moves
Contract Value
F
Poor contract value
OverpayFair ValueGreat Value
The Giants have been paying a premium this offseason, with several contracts that outpace the expected production level. Across 4 contracts, 2 grade out as good value and 0 look like overpays based on comparable deals around the league. The best bang-for-the-buck deal was Joey Lucchesi (B) at $1.5M/yr — getting lhp production well above the price point. The priciest commitment relative to production was Harrison Bader (C-) at $10.3M/yr — the outfielder market may have been richer than the on-field return suggests. Payroll flexibility could become a concern if these contracts don't produce at the expected level.
Public Sentiment
D+
Below-average reception
NegativeMixedPositive
Giants' 2026 moves under Buster Posey have drawn significant criticism from fans and media alike. Of 47 graded moves, 15 landed well with the fanbase, 28 drew mixed reactions, and 4 were viewed negatively. The standout move was bringing in Jared Oliva (A+), which generated the most positive buzz. The most questioned decision was the Jared Oliva cut (F), which drew the sharpest criticism. The overall direction has been well-received — this front office is building with a clear vision.
Draft History (During Tenure)
2025 Draft
R1#13
G
Gavin Kilen—
R3#85
T
Trevor Cohen—
R4#116
L
Lorenzo MeolaAll 2026 Transactions
Signings (17)
Giants sign RHP Logan Webb
signing · RHP
C
Giants sign RHP Blade Tidwell
signing · RHP
B+
Giants sign C Daniel Susac on the
signing · C
C
Giants sign C Daniel Susac
signing · C
C
Giants sign CF Drew Gilbert
signing · CF
C+
News & Buzz
Live Discussion
Auto-moderated fan forum with 5-minute speaker turns
Discussion
Loading discussion...
About this general manager
Buster Posey is the general manager of the Giants, in his 2nd year as the lead executive. FanVerdicts evaluates MLB GMs on the same four-grade framework applied to players and teams: Contract Value Index for the GM's contract portfolio (the deals they signed), Performance for the on-field results of the players they assembled, Sentiment for media and fan perception of recent moves, and Fan Verdict for community voting on the GM's body of work. Current grades for Buster Posey: Contract Value Index F, Performance C+, Sentiment D+, Fan Verdict pending.
Each GM grade is rolled up from the underlying transactions attributed to that GM's tenure. When a GM signs a player, that signing's Contract Value Index grade flows into the GM's portfolio score; the same player's subsequent performance and sentiment grades flow into the GM's respective summaries. Phased attribution applies for new GMs: the first three years weight the prior GM's legacy deals at 100%/66%/33%, ramping the new GM's ownership of roster outcomes.
For broader context, the MLB hub has team rankings, GM report cards, and the transactions feed. The MLB GM rankings page ranks every front office side-by-side on the same four dimensions.