Tyler Guyton

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

Tyler Guyton's rookie deal earns a B- CVI, reflecting solid value for a first-round tackle despite concerning on-field results. The 24-year-old's $3.3M AAV represents excellent cap efficiency for the left tackle position, but his D+ performance grade after appearing in just 10 games during his sophomore season raises serious questions about whether Dallas got the player they drafted 29th overall in 2024. The media narrative paints a troubling picture of a "demoted 1st-round pick" who has failed to establish himself as a reliable starter, with coaching staff framing his 2026 role as a "gamble" rather than a confident investment in their offensive line future. At this stage of his career, Guyton appears to be fighting to prove he belongs as an NFL starter rather than building on early success, making his four-year rookie contract a double-edged sword that provides Dallas cap flexibility while potentially tying them to an underperforming asset. The Cowboys' recent signings suggest they're in evaluation mode, which could either provide Guyton with reduced pressure to develop or signal the organization is hedging its bets on their young tackle's future.

Performance Analysis

Tyler Guyton's D+ grade with the Cowboys is an acceptable return for a first-round rookie tackle who was considered a developmental prospect. Guyton has the physical tools — his size and athleticism are legitimate — but the technique needs refinement before he can be a dominant NFL blocker. His D+ reflects the expected growing pains of a young tackle learning against NFL speed rushers. Dallas' offensive line has needed help, and Guyton has provided enough to be in the starting lineup while not yet being the finished product. His run blocking has been more advanced than his pass protection, which is typical for developmental tackles. Guyton's trajectory suggests steady improvement ahead.

Current Sentiment

Tyler Guyton enters the 2026 season in a precarious position, with the Dallas Cowboys openly outlining a plan that introduces Drew Shelton as a legitimate competitor at his offensive tackle spot. The messaging from the organization, as reflected in multiple recent headlines, signals that Guyton has not yet secured his starting role and faces heightened internal pressure heading into the offseason program. Media coverage has framed his situation as one of urgency rather than promise, with analysts noting he has virtually no margin for error if he hopes to hold off a younger challenger. The broader Cowboys offensive line narrative remains a point of concern for the franchise, and Guyton's name is frequently surfacing in that context as a question mark rather than an anchor. At just two years into his NFL career with limited statistical footprint and a modest contract, Guyton's perception among fans and media is that of a developmental player whose starting future in Dallas is genuinely in doubt.