Seth Coleman

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

The Miami Dolphins took a low-risk flyer on Seth Coleman with this $1.0M AAV deal, but even at that modest price point, this contract earns a D+ CVI that suggests they're paying slightly above market value for what they're getting. While defensive end depth doesn't come cheap in today's NFL, Coleman's unspecified performance tier makes this look like a classic case of paying replacement-level money for potentially below-replacement-level production. The relatively small $1.9M total commitment limits Miami's downside exposure, but the structure still feels inefficient when you consider how many similarly-priced edge rushers typically outproduce this tier of player. For a Dolphins defense that needs reliable depth pieces, this contract represents the kind of marginal roster move that rarely moves the needle — you're essentially betting on developmental upside at a price point where proven commodities usually exist. The deal won't sink Miami's salary cap, but it's the type of slight overpay that adds up when you're trying to maximize every dollar in a competitive AFC East.

Performance Analysis

Seth Coleman is a replacement-level defensive end whose D+ performance grade reflects exactly where he stands in the current NFL talent pool — on the fringes of a roster, not in the conversation for meaningful snaps. His lone stat line — one tackle across one game — tells you everything you need to know about his impact to this point, and there is simply no production to hang a larger narrative on. The most defining characteristic of his profile isn't what he does on the field but rather what his positional ambiguity says about his fit: bouncing between DE and LB designations across multiple organizations signals that no coaching staff has yet identified a clear role for him in a pro scheme. That organizational carousel — stints with the Seahawks, Colts, and Falcons before landing in Miami on a futures deal — is the classic fingerprint of a camp body, a player brought in for roster flexibility rather than projected contribution. At 25 years old in his rookie season, the developmental clock isn't catastrophically short, but the resume of non-commitments from multiple front offices is a significant red flag. The honest outlook here aligns squarely with the media framing: Coleman faces long odds of cracking Miami's 53-man roster, and a practice squad role represents the realistic ceiling entering training camp. With the regular season still 134 days away, there is time to make an impression, but the burden of proof is steep for a player whose NFL footprint has been nearly invisible.

Fan Sentiment

A classic futures/practice squad depth move with minimal immediate impact for Miami. Headlines confirm Coleman has bounced between the Seahawks, Colts, and Falcons organizations without sticking. The key signal is his positional ambiguity — listed as both DE and LB — suggesting he lacks a defined NFL role. Fans won't notice this signing, as it's purely a camp body addition for roster flexibility. Coleman faces long odds of making Miami's 53-man roster but could contribute on a practice squad.