Mike Hall Jr.

Career StatsC-

Year	Team	GP	Sacks	Tkl	TFL
Career		17	2.5	25	7
2025		9	1.5	11	2.5
2024		8	1.0	14	4.5

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

Mike Hall Jr.'s $1.8M AAV extension with the Browns is an absolute steal that earns an A CVI grade. Landing a proven rotational defensive tackle at this price point represents exceptional value in today's inflated market, where even backup interior linemen routinely command $3-4M annually. Hall's production as a reliable rotation piece provides Cleveland with exactly what they need — consistent gap-filling and pass rush contributions without breaking the bank. The $4.4M in guaranteed money offers reasonable security for Hall while keeping the Browns' financial risk minimal, and the modest annual value leaves plenty of cap flexibility for other roster needs. Cleveland's front office deserves credit for locking up a solid contributor before his market value inevitably rises, giving them a foundational depth piece that most teams would pay double to acquire in free agency.

Performance Analysis

Mike Hall Jr. grades as a serviceable starter among NFL defensive tackles — a middle-of-the-pack player at the position. His strongest area is sack production at 0.17 (below the NFL average of 0.21), ranking as below average for the position. Tackling, at 1.22 compared to an NFL average of 2.30, is where he falls short relative to the position. Limited games played (17 career) reduces confidence in this grade.

Current Sentiment

Mike Hall Jr.'s public perception reflects the harsh reality of being a high draft pick who hasn't delivered on expectations through his first two seasons with Cleveland. With only 2.5 career sacks and a narrative centered around injury concerns and limited contributions, the media coverage has grown increasingly skeptical about the defensive tackle's development trajectory. Headlines questioning why he remains on the active roster and suggesting he's "running out of time to calm fans' panic" paint a picture of mounting organizational and fan frustration. The combination of underwhelming production from a player Cleveland invested significant draft capital in, coupled with concerning team announcements that have overshadowed any positive momentum from his injury recovery, has created a toxic cycle of disappointment. His Contract Value Index (CVI) sentiment grade of D- accurately captures this deteriorating public confidence, as both media and fans have begun to view Hall Jr. as a cautionary tale about high expectations meeting harsh NFL reality. The narrative has shifted from patient development to legitimate concern about whether the young defensive lineman can salvage his early career trajectory before Cleveland's patience runs out entirely.