Karsen Barnhart

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

The Packers secured solid value with Karsen Barnhart's $0.9M deal, earning a C+ CVI that reflects getting adequate depth at minimal cost. At under $1 million annually, Green Bay is essentially paying backup money for a tackle who can step in when needed without breaking the bank or creating salary cap headaches. This appears to be a futures contract on a young lineman who showed enough promise to warrant a roster spot but hasn't yet proven himself as anything more than a developmental piece. The low-risk structure gives the Packers flexibility to either develop Barnhart into a reliable contributor or move on without significant financial consequences. While this isn't the kind of signing that moves the needle for a championship contender, it's exactly the type of prudent depth building that good organizations do to maintain offensive line continuity throughout a long season.

Performance Analysis

Karsen Barnhart is a replacement-level offensive tackle whose D+ performance grade reflects exactly what a futures contract signing is supposed to be — a long-shot evaluation, not a roster solution. Appearing in just 4 games as a second-year player, Barnhart has generated virtually no statistical footprint worth anchoring an assessment to, which tells its own story about his standing on the depth chart. His best-case contribution at this stage is interior offensive line depth, a role defined more by roster logistics than genuine scheme value. The honest framing here is that Barnhart is a camp body — one of 17 futures signings the Packers processed in a single batch, which signals organizational indifference rather than targeted development. Green Bay does not appear to view him as a starter-level prospect, and nothing in his two-season résumé challenges that read. With the regular season still 132 days away, training camp is his only real audition, and the 53-man roster is a steep climb from where he currently stands — the practice squad is the realistic ceiling, contingent on a standout summer that nothing in his profile yet suggests is coming.

Fan Sentiment

A classic undrafted camp-body signing with minimal immediate roster impact. One headline specifically notes Barnhart has the best shot among undrafted linemen to crack the 53-man roster. Interior offensive line depth remains a perennial Packers concern, making even long-shot signings worth monitoring. Fans are cautiously optimistic given his reported upside, but expectations remain appropriately tempered. Barnhart projects as a practice squad candidate unless injuries or standout camp performances change his trajectory.