Caleb Tiernan Draft Grade | Round 3, Pick 33 | FanVerdicts

A+

Top 3%Pick Grade

Pick Context

Market Value

Steal

Position

OT · Premium Position

Decision Grade reflects market consensus at the moment of the pick. Teams often have private information the consensus does not.

Scouting Report

Big Board Rank: #67 · Day 2 Value

Caleb Tiernan developed into Northwestern's most reliable offensive lineman over a four-year career, transforming from a raw, athletic prospect into a technically sound tackle with impressive versatility. The Chicago native steadily improved each season, culminating in an All-Big Ten selection as a senior after anchoring the Wildcats' improved rushing attack. Tiernan's combination of natural athleticism, football IQ, and competitive temperament makes him an intriguing mid-round prospect who projects as either a swing tackle or eventual starter at right tackle. His ability to handle Big Ten pass rushers while excelling in zone blocking schemes gives him clear NFL upside, though questions remain about his ability to handle elite edge speed and power at the next level.

Strengths

+Exceptional footwork and kick-slide technique in pass protection, maintaining proper spacing and leverage against edge rushers through disciplined mechanics.

+Natural knee bender with excellent pad level consistency, generating power from his base while staying balanced through contact.

+High football IQ evident in pre-snap recognition and communication, frequently identifying stunts and line games before they develop.

+Versatile skill set allows him to excel in both gap and zone blocking schemes, showing particular effectiveness on outside zone stretches.

+Competitive temperament and finishing ability, consistently looking to drive defenders away from the play and create additional running lanes.

+Strong anchor against bull rushes, using his length and base to absorb power moves while keeping his chest clean.

+Reliable pass sets with consistent timing and depth, rarely allowing edge rushers to get the corner on speed moves.

+Excellent conditioning and durability, never missing practice time and maintaining technique late in games.

+Natural leadership qualities with strong work ethic, serving as a mentor to younger offensive linemen throughout his career.

+Effective in space on screen passes and pulling concepts, showing surprising mobility for his size in getting to the second level.

Weaknesses

-Hand placement can be inconsistent against shorter, quicker pass rushers, sometimes getting his hands too wide and losing leverage.

Recovery speed when beaten off the edge is concerning, lacking the lateral quickness to redirect and re-establish position.

NFL Comparison: Mike McGlinchey

Fan voting will be available once grades are published.

Fan Discussion

Live Chat

1 watching

Loading chat...